Wireless networking is one of several ways to
connect the computers in your home. It creates
a network by sending radio-frequency signals between
your computers to share information.
Please be sure to read the companion article
How
Home Networking Works, which provides information
about configuring your computers, routers and
firewalls, Ethernet networking and sharing an
Internet connection. There are also companion
articles about power-line
networking and phone-line
networking. By the time you finish this series
of articles, you will be able to choose a network
technology that suits your needs and then configure
the whole thing!
In this article, we'll talk about wireless networking
and the technology used to make it happen. We'll
also discuss the advantages and disadvantages
of using a wireless network.
Wireless Networking
Wireless networking technologies take the concept
of "no new wires" one step further. In a wireless
network, all of the computers in your home broadcast
their information to one another using radio
signals. This can make networking extremely easy,
especially if you have computers all over your
house. It also makes it a whole lot simpler to
move computers around. For example, a laptop
with a wireless network card is completely portable
throughout the house!
In How
Power-line Networking Works, we discussed
peer-to-peer and client/server networks. In wireless
networking, a peer-to-peer (or point-to-point)
wireless network means that each computer can
communicate directly with every other computer
on the network. But some wireless networks are
client/server. They have an access point,
which is a wired controller that receives and
transmits data to the wireless adapters installed
in each computer.
There are four types of wireless networks, ranging
from slow and inexpensive to fast and expensive:
Bluetooth
IrDA
HomeRF (SWAP)
WECA (Wi-Fi)
Bluetooth is not widely available yet and is not
expected to replace the need for high-speed data
networks between computers. You can read more about
this cutting-edge technology in How
Bluetooth Short Range Radio Systems Works.
IrDA
(Infrared Data Association) is a standard for
devices to communicate using infrared light pulses.
This is how remote controls operate, and the fact
that all remotes use this standard allows a remote
from one manufacturer to control a device from
another manufacturer. Since IrDA devices use infrared
light, they depend on being in direct line of
sight with each other. Although you can purchase
and install an IrDA-based network capable of transmitting
data at speeds up to 4 megabits per second (Mbps),
the requirement for line of sight means that you
would need an access point in each room, limiting
the usefulness of an IrDA network in a typical
home layout.
Before we talk about SWAP and Wi-Fi, we need
to understand the original standard that both
of these new specifications are based on. The
original Institute
of Electrical and Electronics Engineers wireless-Ethernet
specification, known as IEEE 802.11, designated
two ways of communicating between devices and
allowed for speeds up to 2 Mbps. Both communication
methods, direct-sequence spread spectrum (DSSS)
and frequency-hopping spread spectrum (FHSS),
use the frequency-shift keying (FSK) technology
we discussed in power-line networking. Also, both
are based on spread-spectrum radio waves
in the 2.4-gigahertz (GHz) range.
Spread
spectrum simply means that data is sent in
small pieces over a number of the discrete frequencies
available for use at any time in the specified
range. Devices using direct-sequence spread spectrum
(DSSS) communicate by splitting each byte of data
into several parts and sending them concurrently
on different frequencies. DSSS uses a lot of the
available bandwidth, about 22 megahertz (MHz).
Devices using frequency-hopping spread spectrum
(FHSS) send a short burst of data, shift frequencies
(hop) and then send another short burst. Since
the FHSS devices that are communicating agree
on which frequencies to hop to, and use each frequency
for a brief period of time (less than 400 milliseconds)
before moving on, several independent FHSS networks
can exist in the same physical area without interfering
with each other. Also, due to FCC
restrictions, as well as the fact that FHSS devices
generally send data on just two to four frequencies
simultaneously, they only use 1 MHz or less of
the available bandwidth. Because they use any
given frequency for such a short time, FHSS devices
are less prone to interference than DSSS devices.
But DSSS is capable of much greater speed than
FHSS since these devices can send a lot more data
at the same time. Currently, FHSS-based devices
are easier and cheaper to produce, which has led
the HomeRF group to adopt FHSS as the method of
communication for their products.
HomeRF and SWAP
The HomeRF
Working Group (RF stands for radio frequency)
was an alliance of businesses that developed a
standard called Shared Wireless Access Protocol
(SWAP).
A sort of hybrid standard, SWAP includes six
voice channels based on the Digital Enhanced Cordless
Telecommunications (DECT) standard and the 802.11
wireless-Ethernet specification for data. SWAP
devices make 50 hops per second and transmit at
1 Mbps. Depending on the manufacturer, some of
these can step up to 2 Mbps if there is very little
interference in their operational area.
Here are the advantages of SWAP:
It's inexpensive ($70 to $200 per device).
It's easy to install.
It requires no additional wires.
It has no access point.
It uses six full-duplex voice channels and
one data channel.
It allows up to 127 devices per network.
It allows multiple networks in the same location.
You can use encryption to make your data secure.
Here are the disadvantages of SWAP:
It's not very fast (normally 1 Mbps).
It has a limited range (75 to 125 ft / 23
to 38 m).
It's not compatible with FHSS devices.
Physical obstructions (walls, large metal
objects) can interfere with communication.
It's difficult to integrate into existing
wired networks.
This wireless PCI card
is inserted inside your computer to build
a wireless network.
The actual wireless transceiver, with a small,
integrated antenna, is built into an ISA, PCI
or PCMCIA card. If you have a laptop computer,
the PCMCIA card plugs directly into one of the
PCMCIA slots. For desktop computers, you will
either need a dedicated ISA or PCI HomeRF card,
or a PCMCIA card with a special adapter. ISA and
PCI adapters are inserted inside the computer
and have a slot that is accessible from the back
of your computer so you can plug in the PCMCIA
card. USB
adapters are external devices that you plug the
PCMCIA card into and then connect to a USB port
on the computer. Some of the HomeRF manufacturers
sell kits that include the appropriate adapter
along with the PCMCIA cards and installation software.
Currently, because of the need to use dedicated
cards, only computers can participate in a SWAP
network. Printers and other peripheral devices
need to be physically connected to a computer
and shared as a resource by that computer.
In most cases, SWAP-based networks are point-to-point.
Some manufacturers do offer access points as an
option to increase the effective range of the
wireless network, but they are not required equipment.
Mainly because of this lack of an access point,
HomeRF networks are significantly cheaper than
the other viable wireless network, WECA's Wi-Fi.
But the tradeoffs for cost are speed and distance.
If you can set up a wired network using HomePNA
or traditional Ethernet, you will get 10 to 100
times the speed for the same amount of money or
less. However, unless you plan to send large amounts
of data (like video) back and forth, SWAP speed
is probably adequate for most home use, and the
freedom of no wires can be quite appealing. Just
remember that this is still a developing technology.
The Wireless
Ethernet Compatibility Alliance (WECA) has gone
in a completely different direction from HomeRF.
Targeted more at office use than home networks,
Wi-Fi (for "wireless fidelity", like Hi-Fi
for "high fidelity" in audio equipment) is essentially
a seal of approval that says the manufacturer's
product is compliant with a variation of the IEEE
802.11 specification known as IEEE 802.11b.
This specification drops FHSS and focuses on DSSS
because of the higher data rate it can attain. Under
802.11b, devices communicate at a speed of 11 Mbps
whenever possible. If signal strength or interference
is disrupting data, the devices will drop back to
5.5 Mbps, then 2 Mbps and finally down to 1 Mbps.
Though it may occasionally slow down, this keeps
the network stable and very reliable.
Photo courtesy Nexland The ISB Wavebase by Nexland
allows you to connect wireless devices to
your fast Internet connection.
Here are the advantages of Wi-Fi:
It's fast (11 Mbps).
It's reliable.
It has a long range (1,000 ft / 305 m in open
areas, 250 to 400 ft / 76 to 122 m in closed
areas)
It's easily integrated into existing wired-Ethernet
networks.
It's compatible with original 802.11 DSSS
devices.
Here are the disadvantages:
It's expensive.
It can be difficult to set up.
Speed can fluctuate significantly.
Wi-Fi offers Ethernet speeds without the wires,
but you pay for it. There are Wi-Fi compatible PC
cards that operate in peer-to-peer mode, but Wi-Fi
usually requires access points, which range in cost
from about $300 to $1,400. Most access points have
an integrated Ethernet controller to connect to
an existing wired-Ethernet network. It also has
an omni-directional antenna to receive the data
transmitted by the wireless transceivers. Apple
sells an inexpensive ($299 list) and easy-to-configure
access point called AirPort. AirPort has to be connected
to an Apple computer (iMac, PowerMac, iBook), but
it will accept signals from any 802.11b-compatible
wireless-network card, whether it's PC or Mac-based.
Photo courtesy Apple 54-Mbps AirPort Extreme,
based on the IEEE 802.11g
wireless standard
Like HomeRF systems, the majority of Wi-Fi wireless
transceivers available are in PCMCIA card form.
But some manufacturers do offer PCI or ISA format
cards, not just adapters. The cost per card ranges
from $99 to more than $300. Because these products
are not targeted at the home market, they are
not typically sold in "do-it-yourself" kits. Instead,
everything is a la carte, allowing customers
to build a system that exactly meets their needs.
This is the base unit
of a wireless system used to connect workers
with laptops.
At the HowStuffWorks offices, we have installed
the 3Com
Airconnect wireless system with great results.
Several of our staff members now freely roam about
the workplace with their laptops constantly connected
to the network. We invested about $1,400 for the
access point and three PCMCIA cards. That's not
a bad investment to foster a dynamic work environment,
but is certainly on the expensive side for most
home networks.
If you are a Mac owner, setting up a Wi-Fi-compatible
network is easy, and reasonable in terms of cost.
Otherwise, this is an expensive undertaking that
requires careful consideration of your needs.
In fact, you can buy an inexpensive Apple computer
and an Airport access point for close to the amount
of money you would invest in most other access
points currently available.